Why The Sun and Mail Online Don't Rank As Well As They Could In Google Search

Nov 9, 2021 - 7:41 am 11 by

Google Author Byline

Matt Rogerson, the Director of public policy at Guardian Media Group, posted a Twitter thread dissecting why he believes the claims from The Sun and Mail Online about Google Search mistreating them, are false. He then spent time going through why Google does not rank them well - and it might be heavily around author bylines.

Matt referenced this story on the Press Gazette named The Sun and Mail Online believe they aren't getting fair share of Google search traffic. Matt then references at least two reasons why The Sun and Mail Online don't rank as well in Google Search by The Guardian and other publications. Those reasons are:

(1) Speed issues (2) Issues with original, in-depth, and investigative reporting

The speed issues are easy and I personally doubt it is the main reason why any news organization would not see nice rankings in Google Search. But here is his tweet on that:

It is the original, in-depth, and investigative reporting issues that I found most revealing. In short, it seems like the majority of the news stories The Daily Mail posts are without named authors, named bylines. Matt cites the search quality raters guidelines:

Then he digs into categories of stories and who wrote those stories. Here is how he did it:

Here is what he came up with:

Look at how small the "named byline" slice of the pie is. I am not sure how it compares to The Guardian or other publications but honestly, I am shocked to see this number to be so low.

His conclusion:

What do you all think? Is this the power of bylines or just that this is one signal that the content was not "original, in-depth, and investigative reporting."

Forum discussion at Twitter.

Update: Here is a statement from a MailOnline Spokesperson.

Unfortunately the research in Matt Rogerson's tweets contains a fatal flaw.

He used MailOnline's onsite search function and found 4.8m URLs, of which 50% were wire stories. He assumes this has a detrimental effect on MailOnline’s Google search performance.”

What Matt does not know, because he did not approach us for comment, is that MailOnline blocks Google from indexing agency stories. It’s done automatically in the pages’ code which Google reads. The official term is “apply the noindex value for the meta robots tag to avoid Google indexing this piece of content”.

This means Google does not consider wire stories on MailOnline for ranking. Therefore those stories have zero effect on Google’s ranking of MailOnline original bylined content, which of course is not blocked.

The same applies to the category Matt describes as ‘generic’, by which we believe he means picture galleries, which carry a generic ‘MailOnline Reporter’ byline. The majority of these are blocked from indexing by Google and therefore have zero effect on search ranking.

Another category which may not carry a byline is video. This is indexed by Google, but performs well in search, so does not support Matt’s case.

Finally there is a large category which Matt describes as ‘unknown’. He describes this as ‘total articles minus articles where no author info is available’. We presume Matt means MailOnline author info, because in fact some wire stories also carry bylines. If you subtract the number of articles for which no MailOnline author info is available from the total of all articles, you are left with MailOnline bylined articles. But Matt has already listed articles with a MailOnline named byline separately. If you take all articles then subtract those for which MailOnline author info IS available, you are left with wire stories, galleries and some video – but Matt has also listed them separately so can’t count them again. Whatever Matt means by ‘unknown’ it would appear he has been double counting.

For all these reasons we are afraid Matt’s research has no validity and provides no explanation for why the Guardian performs so much better than other news sites in Google’s search rankings.


Popular Categories

The Pulse of the search community


Search Video Recaps

Google AI Overviews, Ranking Volatility, Web Filter, Google Ads AI Summaries & More - YouTube
Video Details More Videos Subscribe to Videos

Most Recent Articles

Search Forum Recap

Daily Search Forum Recap: May 17, 2024

May 17, 2024 - 4:00 pm
Search Video Recaps

Search News Buzz Video Recap: Google AI Overviews, Ranking Volatility, Web Filter, Google Ads AI Summaries & More

May 17, 2024 - 8:01 am
Google Search Engine Optimization

Remove Your Content From Google's AI Overviews

May 17, 2024 - 7:51 am
Google Ads

Google Ads AI Summaries Live For Some Advertisers

May 17, 2024 - 7:41 am
Google Maps

Order with Google For Food Delivery Going Away End Of June

May 17, 2024 - 7:31 am
Google Search Engine Optimization

Two New Googlebots: GoogleOther-Image & GoogleOther-Video

May 17, 2024 - 7:21 am
Previous Story: Bing Shopping Adds Departments, Stores, Editors Picks, Deals, Pricing Trends & Amazon Integration