Google To Shabbat Observer Webmasters: GoogleBot Is Jewish Also...

Nov 25, 2013 • 8:20 am | comments (8) by twitter Google+ | Filed Under Google Search Engine Optimization

google cloakingThere is this fundamental truth when it comes to GoogleBot, treat it like you would all your other users.

So when someone created a new WordPress plugin named WP-Shabbat, he got into some trouble.

The WordPress plugin shuts down the web site to users when Shabbat starts. In short, the site goes offline to users at around sundown on Fridays and goes back online Saturday night after nightfall.

The only issue, it is "SEO friendly," which means spiders and search engines still can access the site over Shabbat.

The WordPress plugin creator came to Google Webmaster Help after hearing this was not allowed by Google guidelines and asked if that was true. It is true.

Google's John Mueller told the user to treat GoogleBot like all other users:

Treating Googlebot as being something other than a normal user from the same location would be considered cloaking and would be against our Webmaster Guidelines. Using a 503 is fine in situations like this -- it's a sign that your website currently isn't available, and that Googlebot should come back a bit later.

Truth is, it would be neat to just prevent Jewish people from accessing the site. Is GoogleBot Jewish? Too bad there isn't technology for that - just yet.

We've covered the topic a couple times before:

The thing is, most Jewish site owners do not prevent access to their sites on Shabbat. I guess this is something you need to ask your Rabbi about and make sure to also comply with Google's webmaster guidelines.

Forum discussion at Google Webmaster Help.

Previous story: Google Search Suggests "Gay Should Die": Google Policy Team?


Moshe ishot

11/25/2013 01:37 pm

The main questio here is are penguins and pandas kosher?

Fede Einhorn

11/25/2013 05:20 pm

Why "close" the site? People respecting shabbat shouldn't be on a computer anyway. Why going with the trouble?


11/25/2013 08:26 pm

hello, and thanks for covering my plug-in, I did fix the issue and now 503 header is presented, about the Q why close the site its Hilchatic discussion and this is not the place lets just say that there is an oprion to close the site if u decide too. Good luck all

Yossi Medina

11/26/2013 01:32 pm

Barry, I hope you were joking when you suggested to "...just prevent Jewish people from accessing the site..." (had to read it twice to check if i read it right the first time). Are you seriously suggesting Jewish site owners observing Shabbat, should impose Shabbat observance on all other Jewish people? I am sure that's not what you meant, please tell me i read this wrong. If you were just kidding, I may just accept I read only as good as Googlebot. Picking up the content without understanding a thing till i bring it home and have it analyzed by others.

Barry Schwartz

11/26/2013 01:33 pm

I was.

Yossi Medina

11/26/2013 01:33 pm

i am such an idiot then haha : )

James Hall

11/27/2013 12:06 am

NICE plugin drmosko! - I'm sure God was pleased too


11/27/2013 05:33 am

Much appreciated

blog comments powered by Disqus