Google News Should Add a Liberal to Conservative Slider (Filter)

May 5, 2009 • 7:43 am | comments (10) by twitter Google+ | Filed Under Other Google Topics
 

As you know, I bring news and stories to you from my findings in the discussion forums. One of those forums is the Google News Forum.

I always find it funny that every day, without question, there are at least one or two posts from people looking to block either conservative news or liberal news. People get into heated arguments over ways to block either conservative news or liberal news. It is often comical for me to see those headlines, which I normally skip. Just for reference, here is a conservative thread and here is a liberal thread (typically NY Times vs Fox News).

But then it occurred to me, why doesn't Google News give people a way to see news that they want to see. If they like the liberal spin, then give it to them. If they like the conservative spin, then give them that. How?

Remember Yahoo Mindset? The innovative tool from Yahoo that allowed you to filter your search results down by either research results or shopping results. FYI, it was discontinued some time recently. In any event, why not allow searchers to do the same thing with Google News, filter the level of either liberal or conservative spin they get in their news?

There are very few people who would not like such a feature in my opinion. Google is smart, we know your machines can detect bias, so add the slider to filter news towards one bias over an other.

Forum discussion at Google News Forum.

Previous story: Googler Drops Organic Search For Paid Search
 

Comments:

yohaas

05/05/2009 01:19 pm

Then watch the argument over what is considered Liberal or Conservative.

Steven

05/05/2009 04:51 pm

The people won't stand for it because it could be seen as blocking/filtering free speech. Once you start labeling which speech is liberal or conservative, what's to stop someone from putting labels on all other forms of free speech. Conservative writers would cry foul that their right to free speech is being blocked/filtered..and vice versa for the liberal writers.

Barry Schwartz

05/05/2009 05:06 pm

Good points, maybe this is a bad idea. :)

Jeff Revier

05/05/2009 06:27 pm

I think that this would be a great idea. However, I do believe that politics is more complicated than left (government control of economy, more personal freedoms) and right (more freedom economically, less personal freedoms) because there are Libertarians (more freedom both economically and personally) and Statists (government control of economy and personal behavior) that do not fit into that paradigm.

Topper

05/06/2009 01:26 pm

Check out toppersearch.com. It was created in the spirit of Mindset or "biased search". The difference is that the slider can have any bias you choose or build ad hoc. There are several models (i.e. "hats") with some liberal or conservative twist already.

RockyF

05/12/2009 04:10 am

Can anyone point me towards any good reading on the state of the art in slider technology? I use it on Kayak, but don't have a clear sense as to what other applications are out there. Although I agree that a conservative-liberal news source slider might prove to be a minefield, I'd love to play with it.

Jake

05/19/2009 11:35 am

You're a huge power in the media world with your massive readership: 15!

Bill McKay

08/01/2009 02:22 pm

Are you kidding me? Eric Schmidt is a hard core lefty liberal. Google News has 70% of the search market. He wants the bias upheld. Controlling information is the Marxism dream.

Guest

01/19/2011 10:36 pm

Google's success comes from giving people what they want, maybe you should learn how to use it! Personally I like to make my own decision on what is good, bad, left, right, or what have you... I have no trouble finding what I am looking for with Google, educate yourself!

Joe

04/13/2012 10:58 pm

 I don't understand the hostile tone here. It sounds like you don't realize he's talking about google news, not search. And I think a filtering tool would be great. I like a mix of political views, but I want to cut out long running headlines about Lindsay Lohan or some tech thing like Ice cream, whatever the hell that was.

blog comments powered by Disqus