Google News Dropping Publishers From Index

Feb 24, 2009 • 4:36 pm | comments (4) by twitter Google+ | Filed Under Other Google Topics
 

It seems like Google News has been dropping publishers from their index. We have several posts in the Google News Help forum. There are a bunch of threads from upset publishers, including two large threads here and here.

Jason Dowdell, Founder & Editor of MarketingShift.com was one of those publishers who noticed his site being dropped by Google News. Jason told me his site has been in Google News for over 4 years now and as of today, his content is no longer getting picked up. In addition, Jason told me, he no longer sees the "News" tab in Google Webmaster Tools Diagnostics area. To me, that is a clear sign that his site is no longer syndicated by Google News.

As you can see, the last article indexed by Google News from MarketingShift.com was from yesterday, even though, MarketingShift.com has new articles today.

Jason feels like Google is going after the smaller sites making him feel that Google doesn't value the small publishers who work hard to produce "quality content day in and day out." Jason told me that he, "personally spent $25k a year for the past 4 years on MarketingShift, by employing full time writers because we wanted to make sure we remained in Google News and abided by their quality content guidelines."

Mr. Dowdell suspects that Google is dropping the small publishers to help "save the newspaper business." He quoted Google's CEO, in a recent CNN publication, with his solution to help the newspaper industry:

I think the solution is tighter integration. In other words, we can do this without making an acquisition. The term I've been using is 'merge without merging.' The Web allows you to do that, where you can get the Web systems of both organizations fairly well integrated, and you don't have to do it on exclusive basis.

Is Google really going this far to drop small publishers in order to try to save the newspaper business? As far as I know, this site (which is a small publication), is still indexed by Google News.

For all I know, this can be a temporary bug. Google has not yet made a post or commented on these allegations but I will try to get you a comment shortly.

Forum discussion at Google News Help.

Update: Google told me this was an indexing bug. Here is a statement from Google:

Starting earlier today, some publishers noticed that Google News was not crawling their site properly. This issue has now been resolved. We know how important Google News is to publishers, and we take issues like these very seriously.

Previous story: Daily Search Forum Recap: February 24, 2009
 

Comments:

No Name

02/24/2009 10:10 pm

I also have a small news site thats been dropped over the last 4 days i think its a google issue !

Radicke

02/25/2009 09:52 am

I do not think from Google´s perspective it makes sense to drop anyone, especially NOT the small publishers with original relevant content... The "big" publishers (like online news sites) all have the same agency feeds, so it would make more sense to drop those! However, I would NEVER rely on Google News (that is - on ANY single source of traffic) for your business model. In the "real" world, nobody would rely on 1 supplier for the survival of their business, would they?

Peter

02/25/2009 10:01 am

I truly believe it is time for Google to learn appreciate their "Asset" builders and go back to the days when a search engine was a search engine, simple! But why do we complain about Google? We have choices and others grow, too! The world belongs to giants only as long as we are giant food. Instead, we could be the one eating!

No Name

02/25/2009 05:31 pm

The basically want to protect these big news companies or maybe they have a deal going on with them.

blog comments powered by Disqus