Do Small Pages Rank Better in MSN's Live Search

Feb 12, 2007 • 8:28 am | comments (5) by twitter Google+ | Filed Under Bing Search
 

A WebmasterWorld thread has a theory that smaller pages tend to rank better in Microsoft's Live Search (MSN Search), than larger pages.

Senior member, crobb305 explains:

Has anyone else noticed that very small pages rank highest in MSN? This could explain why doorways and blogspots rank so well. To test this, I reduced text on my homepage down to just a paragraph or so, with links to my internal pages. The content reduced from 22k to about 5k. Within 2 days, the page went from page 5 to page 1 for a competitive phrase.

BillyS, another senior member at WebmasterWorld wrote:

I've seen this too. MSN does not seem to care about the number of words on a page. I saw an "About" page rank very high for a competitive phrase - all the page had was about two paragraphs and the phrase was mentioned once.

Honestly, I have no idea. I am sure there are examples of this going both ways.

Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.

Previous story: Google AdSense Down Again Over Weekend?
 

Comments:

gio

02/12/2007 02:19 pm

That's weird. no wonder why i see a lot of irrelevant search results.

Ramenos

02/12/2007 02:54 pm

That's really strange. If it is true, it will be difficult to do a global optimization for a website. You choose : good PR or Live visibility ? It would be surprising if MSN penalises Google indicators...

Rob Abdul

02/14/2007 02:30 am

Yes this appears to be true. Something else that is equally strange is that I have noticed, that sites that at running on Microsoft Internet Information Server (IIS) rank higher on MSN’s Live Search than those running on non Apache or Unix/Linux/Solaris etc.

Benj Arriola

02/14/2007 08:16 am

I noticed this because of an SEO contest where the overall results in all 3 search engines cumulatively determine the winner. But I did not look at it as a site of the site or size of the page. I just based it on keyword density. I noticed all top pages had a keyword density for the targeted term not going over 3%. This is for the over content keyword density and not broken down to each part since the density in the title is still 100% usually. When I decided to post stuff not including the targeted keyword of the contest and just post other related things, the rankings went up on MSN. I started doing this after reading on Webmaster World's discussion on a more strict spam filter seems to be in effect for MSN when they became live search.

Anthony

05/28/2009 05:11 pm

Same thing with me. My sites rank higher on MSN and not even in top 100 on yahoo or google.ds

blog comments powered by Disqus