Google Tests New Format For SEO Office Hours - Do You Like It?

Sep 7, 2022 - 7:51 am 1 by
Filed Under Misc Google

New Google Seo Office Hours

Historically, I mean for over a decade, John Mueller was the single person answering questions from SEOs on the Google SEO office hours segment. Recently John announced changes to the format and it seems like once again, John is making changes to the format.

The format is still not live and it seems to still be once per month but now, John is not the only one answering the submitted questions. Now, John and his team answer the questions. So you have Google's Martin Splitt, Gary Illyes, and Lizzi Sassman answering questions with John Mueller.

It is an interesting format, but I do miss the live Q&A - but that seems long gone. :(

Here is the video followed by the transcript, if you don't want to watch or listen to it:

Lizzi: So the first question that we've got here is from Dimo, a site that connects seekers and providers of household related services matching of listings is based on zip code, but our users come from all over Germany. The best value for users is to get local matches. Is there some kind of schema markup code to tell Google algorithm? Show my site also in the local pack, please note we do not have local businesses and cannot utilize the local business markup code. The site is, and I'm gonna redact that. Yes.

So Dimo as you noted, local business markup is for businesses with physical locations, and that means that there, typically one physical location in the world for that place. so it should only show up for that city. And your other question, currently there's no rich result feature for online services only, that you could use structured data for, but you can claim your Business Profile with Google Business Profile Manager and specify a service area there. So I think that that could help.

John: And now's your chance Martin. Go for it.

Martin: Lalindra asks: Google Search Console shows excellent core web vital scores for our site, but I understand that it only shows details of Chrome users. The majority of our users browse using Safari. Is there a way to measure page experience or the core vitals on Safari browsers? And is there a way to improve the experience?

Well, you can't really use Google Search Console for this, but you can definitely measure these things yourself, with the browser developer tools in a Safari browser, and maybe ask around, if you have any data from Safari users through Analytics, for instance. There's nothing here that we can do this, for the page experience or Search Console's page experience resource, because the data is just not available.

John: For the next question I'll paraphrase. How can I best switch from one domain to a new one? Should I clone all the content or just use 80% of the content? What is the fastest way to tell Google that they're both my sites.

We call this process a site migration it's fairly well documented. So I would look up the details in our documentation. To simplify and leave out a lot of details, ideally, you'd move the whole website, one to one to the new domain name and use permanent 301 redirect from the old domain to the new one. This is the easiest for our systems to process. We can transfer everything directly. If you do other things like removing content, changing the page URLs, restructuring, or using a different design on the new domain that all adds complexity and generally makes the process a little bit slower. That said with redirects users will reach your new site, regardless of whether they use the old domain or the new one

Lizzi: And our next question is from Indiequest1. Do you support the use and the full range of entities? When trying to understand the content of a page outside of use cases, such as rich snippets, can you talk about any limitations that might exist that might be relevant for developers looking to make a deeper use of the standard?

So to answer your question. No, Google does not support all of the entities that are available on We have the search gallery, which provides a full list of what we do support for rich snippets, like you mentioned, in Google search results, but not all of those things are visual. We do talk about certain properties that might be more metadata, like, that aren't necessarily visible as a rich result. And that still helps Google to understand things like authors or other metadata information about a page. So we are leveraging that kind of thing.

John: And next up we have Gary. Hey Gary, which questions did you pick out?

Gary: Anton Littau is asking in Search Console. I get the message sitemap could not be read in the sitemap report. No other information is provided. What could be the reason that the sitemap cannot be read by the Googlebot?

Good question. The sitemap could not be read message in Search Console may caused by a number of issues. Some of them technical, some of them related to content quality of the site itself. Rarely, it may also be related to the hosting service specifically if you're hosting on a free domain or sub domain of your hoster and the hoster is overrun by spam sites that may also cause issues with fetching sitemaps.

Lizzi: Our next question is from Nicholas. Hi John. Well, I'm not John, but anyway, hi Nicholas. We would like to know how algorithms treat cartoon illustrations. We've got guides and tips that are illustrated on our website and they're not performing well in the SERP. We tried to be unique, using some types of illustrations and persona to make our readers happy. Do you think we did not do it right?

I don't know. Cause I don't, I don't think I've ever seen your cartoons , but I can speak to the how to improve your cartoon illustrations in SERP. So our recommendation would be to add text to the page to introduce the cartoons, plus alt text for each of the images. Think about what people will be searching for in Google images to find your content and use those kinds of descriptive words versus just saying the title of your cartoon. hope that helps.

Gary: Chibuzor Lawrence is asking, does posting one content daily increase ranking?

No, posting daily or at any specific frequency for that matter, doesn't help with ranking better in Google search results. However, the more pages you have in the Google index, the more your content may show up in search results.

Lizzi: Okay. And the next question is from Suresh. About the helpful content update that only 10% write quality content and rest 90% don't write quality content, lengthy content, but how should they write quality content? Does Google agree with the word count or not?

Well, nope. Content can still be helpful, whether it's short or long, it just depends on the context and what that person is looking for. It doesn't matter. , how many words, if it's 500 ,1000, if it's answering the user intent, then it's fine. It can be helpful. These are not synonymous things

John: I'll paraphrase. The next question, hopefully correctly in short, when using words from a page title in the URL, should I include stopper words too? For example, should I call a page why is the sky blue dot HTML, or why sky blue dot HTML?

Well, thanks for asking. Words in URLs only play a tiny role for Google Search. I would recommend not overthinking it. Use the URLs that can last over time, avoid changing them too often and try to make them useful for users. Whether you include stop words in them or not, or decide to use numeric IDs, that's totally up to you.

Gary: Sunjay Sanwal is asking, does different bots type, image and desktop share crawl budget. And what about different host?

Fantastic question. The short answer is yes, Googlebots and its friends share a single crawl budget. What this means to your site is that if you have lots of images, for example, Googlebot images may use up some of the crawl budget that otherwise could have been used by Googlebot. In reality, this is not a concern for the vast majority of the sites. So unless you have millions of pages and images or video, I wouldn't worry about it. It's worth noting that crawl budget is per host. So for example, if you have and you have, they have different crawl budgets.

John: Kristoffer asks, we've sold the German sub directory of our website to another company. They request us to 301 redirect the sub directory to their new German site. Would you advise against it? Would it hurt us?

Well, on the one hand, it all feels kind of weird to sell just one language version of a website to someone else. On the other hand, why not? I don't see any problems from redirecting from there to a different website. The only thing I would watch out for, for security reasons, is that you avoid creating so-called open redirects, where any URL from there is redirected to an unknown third party. Otherwise that sounds fine.

Lizzi: Sam Gooch is asking I'm experimenting with the new learning video rich result and can see it's being picked up in Google Search Console. Can I expect to see clicks and impressions from this in the search appearance filter, as we can see with some other rich results?

Well, to answer this question specifically, there's no, guaranteed time that you'll be able to see a specific rich result in Google search after adding structured data. But I think what you're asking about here is for a specific thing to be added to Search Console, and we'll have to check with the team on the timeline for that. And we don't pre-announce when certain things will be added to Search Console. But you can check the rich results status report for learning video and make sure that you're adding all of the right properties and that it's valid and ready to go for Google to understand what it needs in order to generate a rich result. Hope that helps.

John: Roberto asks, we're planning to share the same backend and front end for our two brands. We're ranking quite well with both of them in Google. How big is the risk of penalization?

If we use the same HTML structure, same components, layout, and same look and feel between the different brands, what would be different are the logos, fonts and colors. Or would you suggest migrating to the same front end, but keeping the different experience between the two brands?

Well, this is a great question. Thanks for submitting it. First off. There's no penalty or web spam manual action for having two almost identical websites. That said. If the URLs and the page content is the same across these two websites, then what can happen for identical pages is that our systems may pick one of the pages as a canonical page. This means we would focus our crawling indexing and ranking on that canonical page for pages that aren't identical. We generally index both of them. For example, if you have the same document on both websites, we'd pick one and only show that one in search in practice. That's often fine. If you need both pages to be shown in search, just make sure they're significantly different, not just with a modified logo or color scheme.

Martin: Anna Giaquinto asks, javaScript SEO, what to avoid along with JavaScript links.

Well, the thing with links is that you want to have a proper link. So avoid anything that isn't a proper link. What is a proper link? Most importantly, it's an A HTML tag that has an href that lists the URL that is resolvable. So not like a JavaScript colon URL. And, that's pretty much it. If you wanna learn more on JavaScript specific things for search, you can go to the JavaScript beginners guide on and see all the things that you might want to look out for.

Lizzi: Our next question is from Sakshi Singh. Let's say I research on a keyword, which has no volume or keyword density, but we are appearing for those keywords on the first page. Should we target that keyword?

Well, Sakshi you can optimize for whatever keywords you want it. And it's not always about the keywords that have the most volume. I would think about how people should find your page and target those keywords.

Gary: Kim Onasile is asking. Hello, you previously advised that there are no SEO benefits to audio versions of text content, and that audio specific content doesn't rank separately, like video content. However, given you also said it might be that there are indirect effects. Like if users find these page more useful and they recommend it more, that something that could have an effect. Will audio content be given more priority and independent ranking following the helpful content algorithm update?

This is an interesting question and ignoring the helpful content algorithm update part, no, audio content on its own doesn't play a role in ranking of text results.

Lizzi: Our next question is from JohnMu on Twitter, he's asking, what is the answer to life really?

Well, and that one's easy, John, it's the number 42. I thought you already knew that.

Martin: Someone asked, is it okay to fetch meta contents through JavaScript?

I think that means is it okay to update meta tag data with JavaScript. While that is possible to do it is best to not do that. It may give Google search mixed signals, and some features may not pick up the changes. Like some specific search result type might not work the way you expect it, or it might have incorrect information or it might miss something. So I would suggest not to do that.

Gary: Anonymous is asking. Both of my websites have been hit by different updates, around 90% drops and are suffering from some type of flag that is suppressing our sites until the soft penalty is lifted or is there even a soft penalty?

Good question. No, the named updates that we publish on the rankings updates page on search central are not penalties in any shape or form. They are adjustments to our ranking algorithms. So they surface even higher quality and more relevant results to search users. If your site has dropped in rankings after an update, follow our general guidelines for content. Take a look at how you could improve your site as a whole, both from content and user experience perspective, and you may be able to increase your rankings again.

John: Ayon asks when would be the next possible update for the search results?

Well, on our How search work site, we mentioned that we did over 4,000 updates in 2021. That's a lot of updates. Personally, I think it's critical to keep working on things that a lot of people use. Our users and your users expect to find things that they consider to be useful and relevant. And what that means can change over time. Many of these changes tend to be smaller and are not announced. The bigger ones and especially the ones which you as a site owner can work on, are announced and listed in our documentation. So in short, expect us to keep working on our systems, just like you hopefully keep working on yours.

Lizzi: And our next question is from Dariusz. Hi Dariusz. So Dariusz is asking, does having star aggregated ranking on recipes improve its position?

I think what Dariusz is asking about is the stars that show up for recipes and with structured data and whether or not that has an effect on ranking. So while the stars are more visual and eye catching, structured data in and of itself is not a ranking signal. And it isn't guaranteed that these rich results will show up all the time. The Google algorithm looks at many things when it's creating what it thinks is the best search experience for someone. And that can depend on a lot of things like the location, language and device type.

John: Christian asks. I have set the rel canonical together with a no index meta tag. When Google does not accept a canonical at all, all internal links have dropped. When I don't set a rel canonical, then I can see the internal links in search console in the links report. Is this normal?

Well, this is a complex question since it mixes somewhat unrelated things. A no index says to drop everything and the rel canonical hints that everything should be forwarded. So what does using both mean? Well, it's essentially undefined. Our systems will try to make do the best they can in a conflicting case like this, but a specific outcome is not guaranteed. If that's fine with you for example, if you need to use this setup for other search engines, then that's fine with us too. If you want something specific to happen, then be as clear as possible, for all search engines.

Lizzi: And our next question is from Thijs ,I'm not sure if I'm saying that, right. Thijs. If a video is indexed in the video indexing report, is it still worth adding the video structured data on that page and why?

Well, yes, just because something's indexed doesn't mean that there's not opportunity to improve how it appears. Structured data helps Google understand more about your video. Like what it's about the title, interaction, statistics, that kind of stuff. And adding structured data can make your videos eligible for other video futures, like key moments. So it's not just, oh, get your video indexed. And that's it. There are other things that you can do to improve how your content appears on Google.

Martin: Tamás asked, can I cloak a list with lots of products to Googlebot and show users a load more button.

I think this is not cloaking as what users see when they click on the search result, roughly matches what Googlebot sees. And, if you have a little more button, users will click that. If they don't see the product they're expecting there. So I don't think this is cloaking and that's a solution that I think works from a crawling point of view.

-- -- --

So what do you think? It does sound very much so pre-screened, which I guess is good because the answers are researched beforehand. But I do miss the spontaneous questions and answers, which I assume is what Google wants to avoid...

Also, if you want to submit questions for the next one, you can submit them over here.

Forum discussion at Twitter.


Popular Categories

The Pulse of the search community


Search Video Recaps

Google Volatility, Indexing Bugs, Google Ads Broad Match Default & YouTube SEO Tips - YouTube
Video Details More Videos Subscribe to Videos

Most Recent Articles

Search Forum Recap

Daily Search Forum Recap: July 12, 2024

Jul 12, 2024 - 10:00 am
Search Video Recaps

Search News Buzz Video Recap: Google Volatility, Indexing Bugs, Google Ads Broad Match Default & YouTube SEO Tips

Jul 12, 2024 - 8:01 am
Google Maps

Remove Thumbtack Book Links In Google Business Profiles

Jul 12, 2024 - 7:51 am
Google Search Engine Optimization

New: Google Search Console Let's You Add Your Shipping & Return Information

Jul 12, 2024 - 7:41 am

Google Search Tests Autoplaying Video Thumbnails In Results?

Jul 12, 2024 - 7:31 am
Bing Search

Bing Search Tests Voting On Search Results

Jul 12, 2024 - 7:21 am
Previous Story: Google: Crawl Rate Spikes Not A Sign Of The Helpful Content Update Rollout