Google Instant On iPhone Stinks

Nov 5, 2010 • 8:05 am | comments (4) by twitter Google+ | Filed Under Google Search Engine
 

I have no strong feelings of Google Instant. I think it works well for many people and if they don't like it, they can turn it off. Personally, I don't mind it - even as an advanced searcher.

But yesterday, when Google announced Instant was now available on iPhones (iOS) and Android 2.2 devices, I had to take a look. What I discovered was that, at least on an iPhone, it is a waste of time and not a time saver.

The whole point of Google Instant is to show results instantly based on what you are typing or what you are about to type. The issue with Google Instant on an iPhone is that there is not enough screen real estate to show you the search results as you type.

For example, here is a screen shot of Google Instant in portait mode on my iPhone. You can barely see a piece of the ad:

Google Instant - Where the Results

If you turn your device in landscape mode, forget about seeing even a piece of the search results.

So what is the point of instant results on an iPhone when you can't see them?

Yea, Google let's you easily turn it off, which is what I did. But what's the point? Am I missing it?

I will say, it does look better on an Android device, especially the ones with the larger screens. Here is a video:

Forum discussion at Google Blogoscopd Forums and more coverage at Techmeme.

Previous story: Daily Search Forum Recap: November 4, 2010
 

Comments:

Professor Coldheart

11/05/2010 01:23 pm

A Google Search feature looks better on an Android phone than an Apple phone? To whom is this shocking?

Search Monkey

11/05/2010 09:53 pm

Agreed. Google instant should be pulled from mobile searches. Landscape view should you more characters but is not a time saver.

Harsh Agrawal

11/07/2010 02:07 am

Maybe its just me, but who actually goes to Google search site on their mobile device? especially android users that have a built in search bar app to which instant does not apply? Cool idea but seems to have much more functionality on desktops

Bill Sebald

11/09/2010 10:32 pm

It didn't hit my iPhone yet, but if I ignore Instant on my 27" monitor, I'm definitely ignoring it on my 2" monitor :)

blog comments powered by Disqus