When Is Search Engine Optimization Not Required?

Feb 7, 2007 • 7:35 am | comments (5) by twitter Google+ | Filed Under SEO - Search Engine Optimization

There is a wonderful thread at Cre8asite Forums that has a theory that SEO is always not necessary or required. He gives several examples, each example can be argued with, but that is what makes it fun.

The problem I think is the underlining definition of what search engine optimization (SEO) is.

Does this site require SEO? Heck, I have not changed the the site in ages, all I do is add content. Is adding content considered SEO? Is the style of how I write make my content SEO'ed content? Since my content tends to attract a couple links per article, does that make it SEO'ed?

Here are the examples given in the thread for when SEO is not required:

1. If your website is very specific for certain group of audience and does not require too much of public intervention then yes u do not require SEO. e.g. sites of universities and organizations especially made for students and employees resp.

2. When ur site already ranking well in the search engines, due to brand name etc, and you're satisfied with the traffic n sales the u don't require SEO.

3. When you facing some business fallouts, then u need to concentrate ur resources n energy elsewhere rather than SEO.

4.If you are planning to revamp or redesign your whole site again then go for SEO only after you have restructured your site again.

EGOL, moderator, quickly gave objections to each one and they are valid arguments.

As I scroll down the thread, softplus hits it on the nail.

Of course the larger question is: what is SEO?

I think that is the root issue with the thread.

Forum discussion at Cre8asite Forums.

Previous story: Google's Home Page Has 67 Validation Errors


Chris Beasley

02/07/2007 02:14 pm

If whomever posted that wanted to seem legitimate his first step would have been fully spelling out short 3 letter words that take a fraction of a second to type rather than doing some juvenile shorthand. I just can't take anything written like that seriously.

Barry Schwartz

02/07/2007 02:35 pm

Chris, Why are you always so negative? ;-)

Michael Martinez

02/07/2007 05:25 pm

Search engine optimization is the art of designing or modifying Web pages to rank well in search engines. It doesn't look like you've been SEOing the site (nor do you need to).

Bud Caddell

02/07/2007 08:56 pm

If you're interested, I wanted to drop a line and say that I'm working on covering this topic in my blog -- http://www.passion2publish.com/2007/02/what_is_search_.html I work at a publishing firm, and we're starting to educate the print side of the business with the workings of the web in order to maintain a better well rounded staff.

Travis Blotsky

02/07/2007 09:03 pm

Cre8asite has been on fire the past week or so. Maybe one of these days we will fianally all agree on the "true meaning" of SEO.........excuse me while I bask in my sarcasm.

blog comments powered by Disqus