Google Smacks Down Webmaster Over Panda Update

Apr 4, 2011 • 8:51 am | comments (3) by twitter Google+ | Filed Under Google Search Engine Optimization
 

Google SmacksAs the Farmer/Panda update continues to confuse and hurt some webmasters, we still do not have a solid answer on how to escape this update.

That being said, we had our fair share of fun reporting on the update. But here is a new one.

A webmaster came into the Google Webmaster Help forums complaining that his site tanked due to the Google Farmer/Panda update. People were telling him that the reason his site was impacted was because it had a lot of low-quality content taken from third-party sources. He didn't want to hear it.

So Googler, Wysz who started the Google Panda support thread where Webmasters can come and complain and since then, has given webmasters one tip on how to rescue their site from this update, came in to slap down this webmaster.

Wysz said in short, "Scraping content from another source without adding value violates our guidelines." But the way he documented it was pretty funny, at least to me.

Several people have already noted the core issue with your site, but let me try and state it in relation to our Quality Guidelines, since sites which violate these guidelines may not do well in Google, or may be removed completely.

In our guidelines, we warn against creating pages with little or no original content, and we even have a dedicated Help Center article on the topic which notes scraped (copied) content as an example of something that doesn't add value for users.

Now let's take a look at an example page on your site: http://www.soccerhights.com/usa-vs-argentina/

Here's an excerpt: "United States vs Argentina will execute battle since the U.S. returns to New Meadowlands Stadium to engage in recreation a planet power just the once more."

The first reply to your post from LarGibbon asks if this content was auto-translated or spun, as it doesn't sound quite right.

Now, let's look at a page on a different site: http://www.goal.com/en-us/match/58822/usa-vs-argentina/preview

Here's a snippet: "The United States and Argentina will do battle as the U.S. returns to New Meadowlands Stadium to play a world power once more."

Goal.com says "do battle." Your site says "execute battle." Goal.com says "play a world power." Your site says "engage in recreation a planet power."

Scraping content from another source without adding value violates our guidelines.

I call that, Google Smacks!

Our ongoing coverage and stories on the Content Farmer/Panda update:

Forum discussion at Google Webmaster Help.

Previous story: Bing Search April Algorithm Update?
 

Comments:

Ryan Bradley

04/04/2011 01:26 pm

I think a lot of webmasters are getting mad is because their content racketeering scheme is up. They got caught stealing and using other peoples content and know they're mad that they have to actually create their own content without using copy paste.

Nick Stamoulis

04/04/2011 01:57 pm

Let this be a lesson to webmasters everywhere, don't complain if you don't want to get caught! This isn't the first story I've read about a website owner asking Google to reconsider their site and getting caught red handed using unapproved tactics. If you really want someone from Google to seriously look at your site, there better not be any skeletons in your closet.

Michiel Van Kets

05/16/2012 01:27 pm

really? you still didn't figure out the FARM update? google simply weeding out the crap, the only difference is that they're not tweaking their algorithms; they're de-indexing pages, sometimes whole sites. simpel. so, the answer is is simple; stop using cheap crappy tricks; google is on to you :)

blog comments powered by Disqus