Can You Optimize Your Site with Just Links?

Jul 29, 2008 • 10:15 am | comments (4) by twitter | Filed Under SEO - Search Engine Optimization
 

Shimon Sandler wrote a controversial post about the options available to sites who cannot actually make code changes to optimize their site. He explains that you can build links, and that's perfectly legitimate as it's called "off site optimization."

The question is: does that really help "optimize" the site at all? If the website was poorly coded, will those links really help? Probably not.

Sphinn forum member JohnHGohde notes that this is not SEO at all:

The most positive comment that I can come up with is that link building is called SEM, rather than SEO.

In other words, SEO (search engine optimization) is about optimizing the site, but SEM (search engine marketing) includes all the other factors, like link building.

Further, if you're only going to optimize based on links, you're probably Google bombing. This reminds me of when the SEO community tried to rank Stephen Colbert as the Greatest Living American Dude. That's not the way you're supposed to do it, according to forum members. Further, it can be really difficult to rank at all with a poor quality site; Jill Whalen calls it an "uphill battle."

Other people believe that you can still optimize your site with link building, but that if you do that, you're not doing the complete job. Hugo Guzman says the following:

The proof is in the pudding. It's been done countless times (link-building without site-side). That said, not optimizing site-side elements is definitely an incomplete approach to SEO.

Like I said, Shimon's post was really controversial -- but there are a lot of great comments.

Forum discussion continues at Sphinn.

Previous story: Can You Benchmark Traffic from the Google Keyword Tool?
 

Comments:

Michael Martinez

07/29/2008 02:48 pm

Of course it's link bombing. It's also the number one preferred method for obtaining competitive rankings in the industry. Many commercial sites make absolutely no effort to optimize for search. They just go for links. There should be no controversy around such a mundane post.

gabs

07/29/2008 03:32 pm

The second links effected the serps a seo had to link build... Seo = search engine optimisiation and not site optimisation. IMHO..

Katinka

07/30/2008 09:19 am

It's just foolish to optimize with just links, though I would not call link building SEM. I mean: on site optimization can have such a huge effect, and is often so much easier.

David

07/31/2008 05:09 pm

IMO link building is an integral part of any SEM strategy, although shouldn't be applied singularly. After all, what’s the point of driving traffic to your site if its not optimized for conversion. Sadly links building is often associated with Spamming and a reason why we as SEO's get a bad online rep.

blog comments powered by Disqus